Mistakes Companies Make When Responding to TCPA Demand Letters

A company should handle a pre litigation Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) demand letter by preserving every record tied to the phone number, pulling the full consent and contact history, checking for an arbitration agreement and insurance coverage, and responding only through counsel. The most expensive mistakes happen in the first week, before anyone has looked at the facts, and they tend to convert a few hundred dollars of exposure into a class action.

A TCPA demand letter is rarely a bluff. Many are sent by lawyers who file dozens of TCPA cases a year, and some come from serial individual plaintiffs who know the statute well. The checklist below covers the mistakes those senders count on.

Mistakes in the first 48 hours after a TCPA demand letter

  • Ignoring the letter because the amount seems small. A demand for $1,500 for three calls is often a test of whether the company has consent records, and the complaint that follows usually pleads a class.
  • Calling or texting the sender back from the same dialer or campaign. Every new contact after the letter can be a fresh violation, and plaintiffs invite it.
  • Failing to add the number to the internal do not call list immediately, across every vendor and platform that could reach it.
  • Letting routine deletion run. Call detail records, recordings, dialer logs, consent screens, lead data and vendor correspondence must be placed under a litigation hold the day the letter arrives.
  • Answering the letter directly with facts that have not been checked. A statement that the number came from a lead vendor, or that consent was obtained on a particular website, becomes an admission that is hard to walk back.

Mistakes in investigating the claim

The investigation decides whether the matter is a nuisance payment, a defensible case or a serious class exposure. Skipping steps here is the second most common error.

  • Treating the consent record as a yes or no question. Pull the lead form as the consumer saw it, the disclosure language, the time stamp, the device data and any third party certification of the consent, then ask whether the language meets 47 CFR 64.1200(f)(9).
  • Overlooking the reassigned number and wrong number possibility. Check whether the consent belongs to a different person and whether the Reassigned Numbers Database was queried before the calls.
  • Assuming Facebook, Inc. v. Duguid (2021) ends the matter. The narrowed autodialer definition does not touch prerecorded voice claims, do not call claims or the state statutes in Florida, Oklahoma, Texas and elsewhere.
  • Ignoring the plaintiff. Prior lawsuits, business use of the phone and a pattern of inviting calls bear on standing, on the residential subscriber requirement for do not call claims and on settlement value.
  • Failing to read the vendor contract. Lead generators and dialing vendors often owe indemnification, and a late tender can forfeit it.
  • Failing to look for an arbitration agreement and class waiver in the website terms, the customer agreement or the lead generator’s terms, because an enforceable clause changes the economics entirely.

Mistakes in resolving a TCPA settlement demand

  • Paying the number on the letter. Demands usually multiply $500 or $1,500 by every call ever placed, whether or not each call is actionable, and a short factual response through counsel often cuts the figure sharply.
  • Settling without a written release that covers affiliates, officers, vendors and every statutory theory, state and federal, with a confidentiality term and no admission of liability.
  • Settling before notifying the insurer. Many policies require consent before settlement and treat late notice as a defense to coverage, so review the policy before money moves.
  • Paying for silence without fixing the cause. The same vendor, campaign or dialer setting that produced this letter is likely to produce the next one, and a second letter from the same plaintiff’s firm may cite the first.
  • Forgetting that an individual release does not stop someone else from filing the class action, so the compliance fix matters more than the settlement.

A short response checklist for a TCPA demand letter

  1. Issue a litigation hold and suppress the number everywhere on the day the letter arrives.
  2. Assemble the complete contact history and consent trail for the number, including vendor records.
  3. Check the Reassigned Numbers Database query history and the internal do not call list for prior requests.
  4. Identify every applicable federal and state theory and the exposure under each, including treble damages.
  5. Locate any arbitration agreement, class waiver and indemnification right, and tender to vendors and insurers in writing.
  6. Decide on a strategy, whether a factual response, a negotiated individual settlement or a defense, and have counsel send every communication.
  7. Correct the underlying consent, scrub or script failure before the next campaign runs.

Shipkevich PLLC responds to TCPA demand letters for companies in regulated industries and can evaluate a demand before a company commits to a position.

Frequently asked questions

Should a company respond to a TCPA demand letter?

Yes, but through counsel and only after the consent and call records for the number have been reviewed. Silence usually leads to a filed complaint, often a class action, while a direct response from the business can create admissions. A short, factual response from counsel is the usual first step.

How much is a TCPA demand letter worth?

Statutory damages are $500 per violation and up to $1,500 if the violation was willful or knowing, so the letter will multiply those figures by the call count. The real value depends on whether the company can prove consent, whether the calls were autodialed or prerecorded, whether the number was on a do not call list and whether an arbitration agreement applies. Most individual demands settle for far less than the figure in the letter once those facts are on the table.

Can a TCPA demand letter turn into a class action?

Yes, and many are drafted with that in mind. The complaint that follows an unanswered or mishandled letter typically alleges a class of everyone who received similar calls or texts in the past four years. Preserving records and fixing the underlying problem early reduces both the chance and the size of that case.

Should we call the person who sent the TCPA demand letter?

No, not from any marketing line, dialer or texting platform. Every new call or text after the letter can be a separate violation and may support a finding of willfulness. Add the number to the internal do not call list the same day and let counsel handle all contact.

To discuss how these rules apply to your company, contact Shipkevich PLLC.

Share this article