Insurance Coverage for TCPA Claims

Most business insurance policies written in the last fifteen years will not cover a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) suit, because insurers added an exclusion for claims arising from statutes that regulate the sending of calls, texts, faxes and emails. Coverage can still be found in three main places. Older or non standard general liability forms without the exclusion, directors and officers or errors and omissions policies whose exclusions are narrower than the insurer assumes, and specialty endorsements that insurers sell to companies that market by phone.

The answer for any particular company therefore depends on the policy language, and the time to read it is before a demand letter arrives. A company that markets by phone or text and has never asked its broker about TCPA coverage is likely uninsured for its largest litigation risk.

Where TCPA claims fit under a general liability policy

The commercial general liability policy’s Coverage B insures personal and advertising injury, which the standard form defines to include oral or written publication, in any manner, of material that violates a person’s right of privacy. The first wave of TCPA coverage cases involved junk faxes, and courts split on whether an unwanted fax violates a right of privacy in the sense the policy means.

The Illinois Supreme Court found coverage in Valley Forge Insurance Co. v. Swiderski Electronics (2006), reasoning that an unsolicited fax intrudes on the recipient’s seclusion, and the Florida Supreme Court agreed in Penzer v. Transportation Insurance Co. (2010). The Seventh Circuit went the other way in American States Insurance Co. v. Capital Associates of Jackson County (2004), reading the privacy clause to cover disclosure of secrets rather than intrusion, and the Fourth Circuit followed in Resource Bankshares Corp. v. St. Paul Mercury Insurance Co. (2005). Where no exclusion applies, the outcome still depends on which line of cases the governing state follows.

The TCPA exclusion in most policies written since the mid 2000s

Insurers responded to the fax cases by adding a standard exclusion, originally titled distribution of material in violation of statutes and later broadened under the title recording and distribution of material or information in violation of law. The exclusion removes coverage for injury arising out of any action that violates the TCPA, the CAN-SPAM Act, the Fair Credit Reporting Act or any other statute that regulates the sending, transmitting, communicating or distribution of material or information. Courts generally enforce it as written, and the broadened version reaches state telemarketing statutes as well as the federal law.

Two other exclusions do independent work. The knowing violation of rights of another exclusion removes coverage when the insured acted with knowledge that its conduct would violate the rights of another, which insurers invoke when a complaint pleads willful violations. The expected or intended injury exclusion is argued the same way. A complaint that pleads both negligent and willful violations usually keeps the duty to defend alive under a policy without the statutory exclusion, because the insurer generally must defend if any claim is potentially covered.

Directors and officers, errors and omissions and cyber policies

Management liability and professional liability policies are written on different forms, and their exclusions vary widely. Some contain an express TCPA exclusion. Others contain an invasion of privacy exclusion that insurers read to cover TCPA claims, and the Ninth Circuit accepted that reading in Los Angeles Lakers, Inc. v. Federal Insurance Co. (2017), holding that a TCPA text message claim was inherently an invasion of privacy claim excluded from a directors and officers policy. Policies that exclude only claims for bodily injury, property damage or personal injury may leave room for coverage, and the definitions control.

Cyber and technology policies usually exclude unsolicited communications claims outright, although some carriers offer a buyback. Media liability forms sometimes cover privacy claims arising from content but exclude the manner of distribution. Each of these should be reviewed against the company’s actual marketing practices, and the review should include the definition of claim, the notice provisions and any consent to settle clause, since those terms decide whether coverage survives a demand letter that the company handles on its own.

Are TCPA statutory damages insurable at all

Insurers have argued that the $500 per call figure is a penalty that public policy forbids insuring. The Illinois Supreme Court rejected that argument in Standard Mutual Insurance Co. v. Lay (2013), holding that TCPA statutory damages are remedial and insurable, and most courts to consider the question agree as to the base $500 award. The trebled portion for willful or knowing violations is more vulnerable, both under state public policy and under the knowing violation exclusion, so a company with a strong consent record and a clean opt out history has a better coverage position as well as a better defense.

Steps to secure insurance coverage for TCPA claims

  • Ask the broker, in writing, whether each policy covers TCPA and state telemarketing claims, and obtain the exclusion language rather than a summary.
  • Price a TCPA endorsement or a standalone policy, which carriers offer to companies that market by phone and text, usually with a sublimit, a retention and underwriting questions about consent practices.
  • Require lead generators, dialing vendors and marketing partners to carry coverage that does not exclude TCPA claims, and obtain additional insured status where possible.
  • Give notice to every potentially applicable carrier when a demand letter arrives, not when a complaint is served, because claims made policies and consent to settle provisions punish delay.
  • Have coverage counsel review a denial, since many denials rely on an exclusion that does not match the policy actually issued.

Shipkevich PLLC reviews policy language for companies that market by phone and coordinates with coverage counsel when a TCPA claim is tendered.

Frequently asked questions

Does a general liability policy cover TCPA lawsuits?

Usually not, because most general liability policies issued since the mid 2000s contain an exclusion for claims arising from the TCPA, the CAN-SPAM Act and similar statutes. An older or non standard policy without that exclusion may cover a TCPA claim under the personal and advertising injury provision, although courts split on whether unwanted calls violate a right of privacy as the policy uses that phrase. The exact wording of the policy controls.

Are TCPA statutory damages insurable?

Courts that have addressed the question generally hold that the $500 per violation base award is remedial and can be insured, as the Illinois Supreme Court held in Standard Mutual Insurance Co. v. Lay (2013). The trebled portion for willful or knowing violations is more likely to fall within a knowing violation exclusion or a public policy bar. Coverage still depends on the policy’s exclusions.

Can a company buy insurance specifically for TCPA claims?

Yes, some carriers offer a TCPA endorsement or a standalone policy for companies that market by phone and text, usually with a sublimit, a retention and underwriting questions about consent records, do not call scrubbing and opt out processing. The coverage can also fund the defense, which is often the largest cost in an individual case. A broker who places telemarketing risk can identify the available markets.

When should a company notify its insurer of a TCPA claim?

As soon as a demand letter arrives, and to every carrier whose policy could possibly respond. Claims made policies may treat the demand letter as the claim, and many policies require consent before any settlement, so paying a demand quietly can forfeit coverage. Late notice is one of the most common reasons TCPA claims go uninsured.

To discuss how these rules apply to your company, contact Shipkevich PLLC.

Share this article