Group Versus Individual Legal Plans

A group legal plan is sold to an employer, union or association and delivered to that organization’s members, while an individual legal plan is sold directly to a consumer, and regulators treat the two very differently. Employer sponsored group plans are generally governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, known as ERISA, and are generally exempt from state legal plan licensing, while individual plans carry the full weight of state insurance or registration statutes plus the federal marketing rules. The group versus individual legal plans question is therefore the first structural decision a plan company makes.

The label on the product does not settle the question. A plan sold to the public through an association that exists mainly to sell the plan is an individual plan in the eyes of most regulators, and a worksite plan that the employer merely allows into the building may not be an ERISA plan at all.

What separates a group legal plan from an individual legal plan

In a true group plan the contract holder is the sponsor. The employer, union or association signs the master agreement, members enroll through the sponsor, and the fee is paid by the sponsor, through payroll deduction or dues, or by some combination. The plan is a benefit of membership in the group, and the sponsor stands between the plan company and the individual.

In an individual plan the contract is with the consumer. The plan is sold by telephone, online, through direct mail or through a sales force, it bills a recurring monthly or annual fee to the consumer’s card or account, and the consumer can cancel at will. The plan company deals with the member directly on enrollment, billing, service and complaints.

How employer sponsored legal plans are regulated

ERISA’s definition of an employee welfare benefit plan in 29 U.S.C. 1002(1) names prepaid legal services as a covered benefit, so a plan that an employer or union establishes or maintains for employees is a welfare plan. That brings plan document, summary plan description, claims procedure, reporting and fiduciary obligations, and it brings ERISA preemption of state laws that relate to the plan under 29 U.S.C. 1144(a). Union plans funded through a jointly administered trust operate under the Taft-Hartley Act, which permits trust funds for legal services under 29 U.S.C. 186(c)(8).

The state statutes reviewed here recognize this. Florida’s Chapter 642 does not apply to employee welfare benefit plans governed by ERISA or to legal assistance provided by labor unions to their members, Virginia excludes informal plans within an employment relationship and union assistance to members on employment matters, and North Dakota excludes ERISA plans and informal arrangements within an employment or membership relationship. The exemption covers the employer plan. If the group plan is insured, the insurer writing the coverage remains subject to state insurance law under ERISA’s savings clause.

Selling to employers is also business to business marketing. The Telemarketing Sales Rule exempts most calls between a telemarketer and a business under 16 CFR 310.6(b)(7), although the Telephone Consumer Protection Act still governs automated calls and texts to any cell phone, including a benefits manager’s.

How individual and retail legal plans are regulated

An individual plan is where the state licensing statutes apply with full force. Florida, Mississippi, Michigan, Georgia, Arizona and North Dakota treat the plan as insurance, Virginia and Massachusetts license it under their legal services plan chapters, Texas registers it with the Department of Licensing and Regulation, and North Carolina registers it with the State Bar. Sales representatives are licensed in Florida and registered in Texas.

Federal marketing law is layered on top. The Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 CFR Part 310, requires disclosures before payment, prohibits misrepresentations, regulates negative option billing and governs outbound calling. The Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, 15 U.S.C. 8403, governs recurring memberships sold online. State automatic renewal laws, such as California Business and Professions Code Section 17600 and following, add cancellation and disclosure rules. The TCPA governs calls and texts to prospective members. The bar rules apply through the lawyers, and the Rule 7.3 plan exception permits live enrollment contact only with people not known to need a covered service.

The voluntary worksite plan and the ERISA safe harbor

Many legal plans are sold at the worksite as a voluntary benefit the employee pays for entirely through payroll deduction. The Department of Labor’s safe harbor at 29 CFR 2510.3-1(j) keeps such a program outside ERISA if the employer makes no contribution, participation is completely voluntary, the employer’s only roles are to permit publicity, collect payroll deductions and remit them without endorsing the program, and the employer receives no consideration beyond reasonable compensation for the payroll work.

An employer that selects the plan, puts its name on it, negotiates the terms or encourages enrollment has endorsed it, and the safe harbor is gone. The safe harbor is also written for group or group type insurance programs offered by an insurer, so a noninsured membership plan should not assume it applies without analysis. A voluntary plan outside ERISA is generally treated as an individual plan for state law purposes, and the state licensing and marketing rules apply.

Choosing the structure before launch

A plan company that wants the ERISA model needs a sponsor that establishes and maintains the plan, a plan document and summary plan description, a claims procedure and a reporting plan. A plan company that wants the retail model needs the state licenses or registrations that each target state requires, sales licensing where required, a Telemarketing Sales Rule and TCPA compliance program, and billing practices that satisfy the negative option and automatic renewal rules. A company that runs both should keep the two products, the two sets of documents and the two sales channels separate so that a regulator reviewing one does not find the other inside it. Shipkevich PLLC advises plan companies on choosing and documenting the structure that fits their market.

Frequently asked questions

Is an employer legal plan subject to state insurance licensing?

Generally not. A plan an employer establishes and maintains for its employees is an ERISA welfare plan, and Florida, Virginia, North Dakota and other states exclude ERISA plans and union legal assistance programs from their legal plan statutes. If the plan is insured, the insurer that writes the coverage remains subject to state insurance law.

Is a voluntary payroll deduction legal plan an ERISA plan?

Not if it meets the Department of Labor safe harbor at 29 CFR 2510.3-1(j). The employer must make no contribution, participation must be completely voluntary, the employer must limit itself to allowing publicity and collecting and remitting payroll deductions without endorsing the plan, and it must receive no consideration beyond reasonable compensation for the payroll work. An employer that endorses or selects the plan brings it inside ERISA.

Do the same marketing rules apply to group and individual legal plans?

No. Sales to employers are business to business calls that the Telemarketing Sales Rule largely exempts, while sales to consumers are fully subject to the rule’s disclosure, misrepresentation, negative option and calling restrictions. The TCPA applies to automated calls and texts to cell phones in both channels.

Can an association sell a group legal plan to the public?

It can offer a plan to its members, but regulators look at substance. An association formed mainly to sell the plan, with membership open to anyone who buys it, will usually be treated as selling an individual plan subject to state licensing and the consumer marketing rules.

To discuss how these rules apply to your company, contact Shipkevich PLLC.

Share this article