When a Debt Settlement Company Can Collect a Fee Under the TSR

A debt settlement company may collect a fee only after three things have happened. It must have settled or otherwise altered at least one of the consumer’s debts under an agreement the consumer has executed, the consumer must have made at least one payment under that agreement, and the fee must be calculated using one of the two methods the rule permits. Those conditions come from the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR), at 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5)(i), and they generally apply to a company that enrolls consumers by telephone.

This article explains each condition, the two permitted fee methods, and the mistakes that most often turn a fee structure into an enforcement problem.

The three conditions in 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5)(i)

The first condition is a completed settlement. The seller or telemarketer must have renegotiated, settled, reduced or otherwise altered the terms of at least one debt pursuant to a settlement agreement, debt management plan or other valid contractual agreement executed by the customer. A verbal offer from a creditor is not enough. An agreement the consumer has not signed or otherwise accepted is not enough either.

The second condition is a payment. The customer must have made at least one payment under that settlement agreement to the creditor or debt collector. In practice, this means the first settlement payment must leave the dedicated account before the company’s fee for that debt can be drawn.

The third condition is the fee formula, discussed next. All three conditions apply debt by debt. Settling one debt earns the fee on that debt only, not a fee on the whole program.

The two fee calculation methods the TSR allows

The TSR permits two methods and no others. Under the proportional method, the fee for a settled debt must bear the same proportional relationship to the total fee as the individual debt amount bears to the entire debt amount at enrollment. Under the savings method, the fee is a percentage of the amount saved, meaning the difference between the enrolled balance and the amount paid to satisfy the debt, and the percentage must be the same for every debt in the program.

Here is how the two methods work with illustrative numbers. Suppose a consumer enrolls $20,000 of debt across four accounts and one $5,000 account settles for $2,500. If the company’s contract sets a total program fee of 25 percent of enrolled debt, or $5,000, the proportional fee for that settlement is $1,250, because the settled debt was one quarter of the enrolled total. If the contract instead sets a fee of 30 percent of savings, the fee for that settlement is $750, because the consumer saved $2,500.

Both methods should be fixed in the enrollment agreement. A company generally cannot switch methods after the fact, and it cannot charge a higher percentage on the easy debts and a lower percentage on the hard ones.

What counts as a settlement and a payment

Enforcement cases have turned on how loosely a company reads the first two conditions. A creditor’s agreement to accept a lower balance, documented in writing and accepted by the consumer, is a settlement. A hardship program or a reduced interest rate accepted by the consumer also qualifies, because the rule covers any alteration of the terms of the debt. What does not qualify is a debt that the consumer settled directly without the company’s involvement, a debt that was charged off and simply went quiet, or a debt the creditor sold to a buyer who has not agreed to anything.

The payment condition is read literally. The rule says the customer must have made at least one payment pursuant to the agreement. A fee drawn on the same day the settlement is signed, before any money reaches the creditor, violates the rule even if the payment is scheduled for the following week.

Once a fee is earned, the TSR does not dictate the collection schedule. Many companies collect the earned fee in installments that track the consumer’s settlement payments, which keeps the dedicated account balance available for the next settlement. State law or the company’s own contract may limit the schedule further.

Common fee timing mistakes that trigger TSR enforcement

The most common mistake is a fee by another name. Enrollment fees, setup fees, consultation fees, document preparation fees, monthly maintenance fees and retainer fees are all fees requested before a settlement, and the rule bars them regardless of the label. Routing the fee through an affiliated law firm or a separate services company does not change the analysis, because the TSR has no attorney exemption and the assisting and facilitating provision in 16 CFR 310.3(b) reaches the affiliate.

A second mistake is using the dedicated account provider to sweep fees automatically on settlement execution rather than on first payment. The account administrator must be independent under 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5)(ii), but the debt settlement company still controls the fee instructions, and regulators generally treat an early sweep as the company’s violation.

A third mistake is changing the percentage between debts, or applying the savings method to some debts and the proportional method to others. A fourth is charging a fee on a debt that was settled by the consumer, a prior company or a bankruptcy.

State fee timing and fee cap rules layered on top of the TSR

The TSR sets the floor, not the ceiling. Many state debt settlement statutes copy the TSR’s timing conditions and then add a cap. Illinois limits the settlement fee to 15 percent of savings plus a single enrollment fee of no more than $50. Virginia allows no more than 20 percent of the enrolled principal or 30 percent of the savings. Delaware caps all fees at 18 percent of the total principal amount of the enrolled debt. Other states, including Colorado, Nevada, Utah and Pennsylvania, restate the TSR’s two methods without adding a specific percentage.

A multistate company therefore needs a fee schedule that satisfies the TSR everywhere and the strictest applicable cap in each state where it enrolls consumers. The firm reviews fee structures and enrollment agreements for debt settlement companies and can help build a schedule that holds up under both federal and state review.

Frequently asked questions

When can a debt settlement company legally charge its fee?

Under 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5)(i), the fee for a debt may be charged only after the company has settled or altered that debt under an agreement the consumer has executed, and the consumer has made at least one payment to the creditor under that agreement. The fee must also be calculated under one of the two methods the rule permits.

Can a debt settlement company charge a monthly fee or an enrollment fee?

Not before a settlement, when the TSR applies. Any fee requested or received before at least one debt is settled and paid on violates the TSR, whatever the fee is called. States such as Illinois allow a small enrollment fee by statute, but the TSR still bars collecting it before the first settlement when the consumer was enrolled by telephone.

How is a debt settlement fee calculated under the TSR?

The fee must either bear the same proportion to the total program fee as the settled debt bore to the total enrolled debt, or be a fixed percentage of the amount saved on that debt. The percentage of savings must be the same for every debt in the program, and the method must be set in the enrollment agreement.

Does the TSR limit how much a debt settlement company can charge?

No. The TSR regulates when and how a fee is calculated, not the amount. Fee caps come from state law, and several states limit settlement fees to a percentage of savings or of the enrolled principal.

To discuss how these rules apply to your company, contact Shipkevich PLLC.

Share this article