Advertising Savings Claims for Debt Relief Programs

A debt relief company can safely advertise savings only if the claim reflects what its customers actually achieve, calculated across everyone who enrolled, including those who dropped out, and net of the company’s fees. That is the standard the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) set when it amended the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) in 2010, and it is the standard the FTC, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and state attorneys general apply to debt relief savings claims today. A claim that describes only the best outcomes, or that ignores fees, is likely a misrepresentation no matter how it is footnoted.

What the TSR says about debt relief savings claims

The TSR prohibits misrepresenting any material aspect of a debt relief service. The rule at 16 CFR 310.3(a)(2)(x) lists examples, and the first one is the amount of money or the percentage of the debt amount that a customer may save by using the service. The same provision reaches the amount of time needed to achieve the represented results, the amount of money the customer must set aside before a settlement is attempted, the effect of the service on creditworthiness and collection efforts, and the percentage or number of customers who attain the represented results.

The TSR also requires affirmative disclosures before the customer consents to pay. Under 16 CFR 310.3(a)(1)(viii), the company must disclose how long it will take to achieve the represented results, how much money or what percentage of each debt the customer must accumulate before the company will make a settlement offer, the consequences of stopping payments to creditors if the program advises that, and the customer’s rights in any dedicated account. The advance fee ban at 16 CFR 310.4(a)(5) means the company cannot collect a fee on any debt until that debt is settled, the customer has agreed to the settlement and the customer has made at least one payment under it. The TSR applies to inbound and outbound telemarketing, and the FTC and state attorneys general apply the same deception standard to web and print advertising under Section 5 of the FTC Act and state law.

How the FTC expects savings claims to be calculated

The FTC’s business guidance on debt relief services and the TSR explains the arithmetic. In calculating the results achieved over time, a company must include customers who dropped out or otherwise failed to complete the program. A claim built only on settled accounts or on graduates overstates what a new customer should expect. Fees reduce savings. If a customer’s debt was reduced by five thousand dollars and the customer paid a fee of one thousand dollars, the truthful savings claim is four thousand dollars, not five thousand.

Regulators also look at the base. A claim that the company settles debts for half the balance is a claim about individual settlements, and consumers often read it as a claim about their whole program. If the typical customer settles only some enrolled debts, the program level savings figure is lower, and that is the figure consumers care about. The safest claims state the net savings as a percentage of enrolled debt across all enrolled customers over a defined period, and the file that supports the number should be refreshed regularly.

Debt relief advertising compliance checklist

  • Build the savings figure from all customers who enrolled in the measurement period, including cancellations and dropouts.
  • Deduct the company’s fees from the gross debt reduction before stating a savings amount or percentage.
  • State the savings as net savings on enrolled debt, and keep the data set, the formula and the date range in a substantiation file.
  • Refresh the figure on a set schedule and pull any ad that relies on an outdated number.
  • Match the time claim to actual completion data. If most customers take three or four years to finish, do not advertise results in months.
  • Disclose the accumulation requirement, the time to results, the consequences of missed creditor payments and the dedicated account rights before the customer agrees to pay.
  • Never describe fees as earned or due before a settlement meets the three conditions of the advance fee ban.
  • Avoid words that imply certainty, such as eliminate, erase or guaranteed, unless the company can prove the outcome for every customer.
  • Do not compare the program to bankruptcy or credit counseling without substantiating the comparison.
  • Route every ad, script and landing page through a documented review that checks each claim against the substantiation file.

Timelines, guarantees and testimonials about savings

A timeline claim is a savings claim in disguise, because consumers assume the result arrives when the company says it will. The TSR requires the company to disclose, before enrollment, the amount of time necessary to achieve the represented results. Guarantees are one of the fastest routes to an enforcement action, since no debt settlement program can guarantee that a creditor will accept an offer.

Testimonials are subject to the FTC Endorsement Guides, 16 CFR Part 255. A customer who says the program cut their debt in half is likely understood to be saying that other customers can expect the same, and the company must either substantiate that or clearly and conspicuously disclose the generally expected result. A results not typical disclaimer does not cure the problem. Each of these points generally applies with equal force under state unfair or deceptive acts and practices statutes, and several states have added their own debt settlement advertising rules. Shipkevich PLLC reviews advertising, scripts and substantiation files for debt relief companies and defends them in state and federal investigations.

Frequently asked questions

Can a debt settlement company advertise an average savings percentage?

Yes, if the percentage reflects the net savings of all customers who enrolled during the measurement period, including those who dropped out, after the company’s fees are deducted. The company must keep the data and the calculation that support the number and must update the claim as results change.

Do savings claims have to include customers who dropped out?

Yes. The FTC’s guidance on debt relief services under the TSR states that a company calculating its results must include customers who dropped out or otherwise failed to complete the program. A figure based only on completed settlements or program graduates overstates what a new customer should expect.

Is it deceptive to say a program can settle debts for half the balance?

It can be. A claim about individual settlement percentages implies a claim about overall program results, and if the typical customer does not achieve that across their enrolled debts, the net impression is misleading. The company also must account for its fees, which reduce the savings the consumer actually receives.

Can a debt relief company guarantee results?

No. Creditors are not required to accept settlement offers, so a guarantee of a particular savings amount or percentage generally cannot be substantiated. The TSR treats a misrepresentation about savings as a violation, and regulators treat guarantees as deceptive under the FTC Act and state law.

To discuss how these rules apply to your company, contact Shipkevich PLLC.

Share this article