A trading advisor must register as a commodity trading advisor (CTA) with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) once it advises others, for compensation, on trading futures, options on futures, swaps or retail forex. The usual way around CTA registration is an exemption in Section 4m of the Commodity Exchange Act or CFTC Regulation 4.14. The exemptions used most often are the 15 person rule, the rules for registered investment advisers whose commodity advice is incidental to a securities business, and the rules for advisers that advise only their own pools.
The definition is wide. Section 1a(12) of the Commodity Exchange Act treats as a CTA any person who, for compensation or profit, advises others on the value of or the advisability of trading commodity interests. It also covers anyone who issues analyses or reports about commodity interests as part of a regular business. Compensation can be indirect, and advice delivered through a managed account, a model portfolio, a signal service or a newsletter all counts. Since the Dodd-Frank Act, advice about swaps counts as well.
The 15 person exemption from CTA registration
Section 4m(1) of the Commodity Exchange Act, codified at 7 U.S.C. 6m(1), exempts a CTA that has not furnished commodity trading advice to more than 15 persons during the preceding 12 months and that does not hold itself out generally to the public as a CTA. Regulation 4.14(a)(10) repeats the same test. The exemption is self executing, so no notice is filed with the National Futures Association (NFA).
Both halves matter. A firm with five clients that advertises its futures program on a website, speaks at conferences about its track record or posts performance on social media is holding itself out to the public. It likely loses the exemption even though it is well under 15 clients. How clients are counted also matters, and a firm near the line should count conservatively and get advice before adding the next account.
CTA exemptions for registered investment advisers
Section 4m(3) of the Commodity Exchange Act exempts an adviser registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) whose business does not consist primarily of acting as a CTA. The adviser also may not advise any commodity pool engaged primarily in trading commodity interests. This statutory exemption needs no filing. It fits a traditional securities adviser that uses a few futures or swaps in client portfolios.
Regulation 4.14(a)(8) is the regulatory version and it reaches investment advisers that are either SEC registered or exempt from SEC registration. The adviser’s commodity interest advice must be directed solely to listed categories of clients, including registered investment companies, pools operated under Regulations 4.5 or 4.13 and certain offshore pools. The advice must also be solely incidental to its securities advisory business. Unlike the statutory exemption, Regulation 4.14(a)(8) requires an electronic notice to NFA and an annual affirmation within 60 days after the calendar year ends.
Exemptions tied to other registrations and to impersonal advice
Regulation 4.14(a)(4) exempts a registered CPO whose advice is directed solely to the pools it operates, and Regulation 4.14(a)(5) does the same for an operator that is exempt from CPO registration. Regulation 4.14(a)(6) exempts a registered introducing broker whose advice is given solely in connection with its brokerage business. Earlier paragraphs of the rule cover dealers, processors and other commercial firms whose advice is solely incidental to their business, and certain nonprofit membership organizations.
Regulation 4.14(a)(9) covers impersonal advice. A person who does not direct client accounts and does not provide advice based on or tailored to the commodity interest or cash market positions of particular clients is exempt. Publishers of newsletters, research services and general trading education programs often rely on this paragraph, but it disappears the moment the service offers one subscriber a recommendation built around that subscriber’s positions.
What CTA registration requires when no exemption applies
Registration runs through NFA. The firm files Form 7-R with a $200 application fee and each principal and associated person files Form 8-R with an $85 fee. Annual NFA dues are $750, or $2,500 if the firm advises on retail forex or swaps. At least one principal must be a registered associated person, which ordinarily means passing the Series 3 examination, although NFA offers a waiver for CTAs principally engaged in securities transactions.
A registered CTA that directs client accounts delivers a disclosure document that meets Regulation 4.31 and is filed with NFA before first use, and it may not use a disclosure document that is more than 12 months old. Performance must be presented under Regulation 4.35, and promotional material must comply with NFA Compliance Rule 2-29. The CTA files Form PR with NFA within 45 days after each calendar quarter, with a $200 per day late fee, completes the Self Examination Questionnaire every year and keeps its Member Questionnaire current. A CTA that advises only qualified eligible persons can claim Regulation 4.7 relief from the disclosure document rules.
Registration also changes who will do business with the firm. Under NFA Bylaw 1101, a futures commission merchant may not carry accounts directed by an unregistered person who is required to be registered. FCMs therefore generally check BASIC and ask for exemption documentation before accepting trading authority from an adviser.
The firm advises trading advisors on exemption analysis, NFA exemption notices and full CTA registration when the exemptions run out.
Frequently asked questions
When does a trading advisor have to register as a CTA?
Registration is required once a person advises others for compensation on trading futures, options on futures, swaps or retail forex, or publishes analyses about those markets as a regular business. The advisor can generally stay unregistered only if a statutory or regulatory exemption applies, such as the 15 person rule or one of the Regulation 4.14 exemptions.
What is the 15 person exemption for CTAs?
Section 4m(1) of the Commodity Exchange Act exempts a CTA that has not furnished commodity trading advice to more than 15 persons in the preceding 12 months and does not hold itself out generally to the public as a CTA. No filing is required, but public marketing of the advisory business can defeat the exemption.
Does a registered investment adviser need to register as a CTA?
Not always. Section 4m(3) exempts an SEC registered adviser whose business is not primarily commodity advice and that does not advise a pool engaged primarily in commodity trading. Regulation 4.14(a)(8) offers a broader exemption for advisers whose commodity advice is solely incidental to their securities business, but it requires a notice filing with NFA and an annual affirmation.
Does advising on swaps require CTA registration?
Yes. Since the Dodd-Frank Act, swaps are commodity interests, so advice about swaps for compensation triggers the CTA definition in the same way as advice about futures. The same exemptions apply, and an adviser that handles swaps and registers pays the higher NFA dues tier.
To discuss how these rules apply to your company, contact Shipkevich PLLC.